Jan 26 ====== Johnson:2006a ------------- (Page 2) Is a reason known as to why in Fig. 1 the Bark-Score for the first formant was significantly lower for French compared to other roman languages like Italian an Spanish? (Page 10) Why does the representation of the collection of non-auditory episodic experience through a single node allow the model to be focussed on auditory/perceptual emergent generalizations? Johnson (2006) cites Strand (2000) that talks about how listeners perceive different talkers, and Strand uses monosyllabic words as tokens. Were monosyllabic words used to control for stress and/or intonation? I would like some clarification on what resonance is and its role in the neural network being implemented in the model (at least this is my understanding of what I've read). Why does the model have a harder time with non-stereotypical male speech? How does the sociophonetic variation in gender differences, as discussed in the paper, challenge traditional theories of speech perception that assume hardwiring as the key to overcoming variability? Additionally, how does the proposed exemplar-based model with resonance contribute to our understanding of speech perception and the emergence of social identity and phonology? Are there any other reasons that can account for these great cross-linguistic differences in formant frequency regarding height differences? For example for Icelandic andBelgian Dutch there is a similar average height difference, however, they differ greatly in F3. They say that "People (perhaps especially men) perform gender". Why would men perform gender more than women? They also state that "In exemplar-based modeling we have to decide what a linguistic experience is, because exemplars are ‘‘experienced instances’’ of language" and then argue that nonconscious brain states or events are not experiences. Why is that? Even when we perceive something unconciously, we still experience it, don't we? It is also interesting to note that even in the same language there are formant differences between male and female speakers of different dialects.