Tense, Aspect and Aktionsarten: Phenomena and Problems
The following is a listing of phenomena and problems to be explained by any
adequate semantic theory of
tense, aspect and Aktionsarten in English.
Tense forms in English:
tense
|
"simple"
|
perfect
|
progressive
|
perfect progressive
|
(1) present
|
I walk
|
I have walked
|
I am walking
|
I have been walking
|
(2) past
|
I walked
|
I had walked
|
I was walking
|
I had been walking
|
(3) future
|
I will walk
|
I will have walked
|
I will be walking
|
I will have been walking
|
What is the difference in meaning between
(4) the simple forms vs. the progressive forms (e.g. John smokes
vs. John is smoking)
(5) the simple past vs. the present perfect: I
walked vs. I have walked
How can we account for the acceptability and non-acceptability of the
following sentences:
(6) John smoked yesterday
(7) * John smoked tomorrow ("*" indicates
non-acceptability)
(8) * John has smoked yesterday
(9) John has not come yet vs.
* John did not come yet
(10) John walked for 2 hours * John built
a house for 2 hours John was building a house
for 2 hrs
(11) *John walked in 2 hours John built
a house in 2 hours
(12) John loved Mary for 2 years *John
died for 2 hours John was dying for 2 hours
(13) *John loved Mary in 2 years John
died in 2 hours
(14) John walked
John was walking
(15) John built a house
John was building a house
(16) John died
John was dying
(17) John knew English *John
was knowing English
(|= means "implies (logically)"; |≠ means "does not imply
(logically)")
(18) John is walking
|= John has walked, John will
have walked
(19) John was walking
|= John walked
(20) John is building a house |≠
John has built a house, John will have built a house
(21) John is dying
|≠
John has died, John will have died
(22) John is growing up |=
John has not grown up (yet)
(23) John is dying
|= John has not died (yet)
(24) John finished building the house
vs. *John finished walking
(25) John stopped walking |=
John has walked
(26) John stopped growing up |≠ John
has grown up
(27) John stopped growing up |= John
has not grown up (yet)
(28) John smokes
vs. John is smoking
(29) John is rude
vs. John is being rude
(30) John ate an apple in 2 hours vs.
*John ate an apple for 2 hours
(31) *John ate apples in 2 hours
vs. John ate apples for 2 hours
(32) *The soldier(s) crossed the border for 2 hours
vs. Soldiers crossed the border for 2 hours